Yes, I am writing a post about chocolate tasting. Milk chocolate tasting to be exact. I got started on this idea when I was on a website and received a request to fill out a survey. The survey asked me to list as many brands of chocolate as I could. I think I was able to list four and this got me to wondering if there was really a difference in the various brands of chocolate. Is one brand of milk chocolate like another brand of milk chocolate?
As this idea blossomed into a full out chocolate tasting, I decided to do the chocolate tasting in two parts. The first part would be without any knowledge of how to do a chocolate tasting and the second part would be done after having done a little research on the proper way to do a chocolate tasting. My aim here was to have a layman's perspective and an educated perspective.
So here is how we set up our layman's perspective chocolate tasting. Raymond and I purchased 10 brands of milk chocolate - two of which had something extra in them besides the milk chocolate. We included these two because either we couldn't find that brand's plain milk chocolate or that was the brand's version of plain milk chocolate. We did the tasting in the evening and water and milk were made available for cleansing the palate between chocolates. Small chunks of each chocolate were placed on a plate according to the numbers on a clock. We recorded in a notebook which chocolate was at which number. This was done to try to discourage bias towards particular brands. We then tasted each chocolate and made comments accordingly. We then put down our top three favorites.
Here is a list of the 10 chocolates:
Toblerone (with honey and almond nougat)
Godiva
Rittersport with Cornflakes
Milka
Dove
Lindt
Hershey's Symphony
Cadbury
Ghirardelli
Hershey's
Our favorites from round one all came from the first 6 chocolates we tasted. By the end of the first tasting, we realized that we had not properly cleansed our palates between chocolates, and the last four chocolates all tasted a little odd. Our taste buds had been overwhelmed, and the results may likely reflect that fact. We did discover that yes, there is a difference between brands of chocolate. Our favorites tended to be the ones with the smoothest, softest chocolate that melted easily in the mouth. The Lindt had a creamy center that was a pleasant surprise after all the solid chocolates we had tasted. Also, the Ghirardelli had a fruity flavor to it that was a delightful surprise. The Cadbury had a nice slightly stronger cocoa flavor to it and we both found we liked the chocolates that had something in them such as the Rittersport and the Toblerone.
My Top Three:
Toblerone
Lindt
Rittersport with Cornflakes
Raymond's Top Three:
Toblerone
Rittersport with Cornflakes
Milka
The research I did on chocolate tasting came from one website. The suggestions were to have no more than 6 chocolates in a tasting session. For more than six chocolates in a tasting session, they suggested waiting at least 15 minutes before continuing with the tasting to allow the taste buds to recover. AllChocolate recommends the chocolate be at room temperature (65-72 degrees F). Their palate cleansing suggestions included water (also at room temperature), unsalted crackers, and plain white bread. The website also notes that it is best to have a tasting follow a light meal.
When grading the chocolate, they recommend assessing aroma, texture, flavor notes, and the order in which you experience the flavors (such as at the beginning, in the middle, and at the end). This website goes on to suggest beginning by looking at the chocolate, then touching it (get an idea of its firmness), break the chocolate and listen for the snap, smell the chocolate, and so on.
Ray and I didn't follow most of this for the second tasting, which took place about two weeks after the first tasting. We changed our method by doing only 5 at a time and had water and (salted) crackers to cleanse the palate between chocolates. We then finished the last 5 the next day.
Sadly, I don't think some of the chocolate stood the test of time very well because several had very different flavors the second time around. This could have been due in part to overwhelmed tastebuds in the first tasting, but I think it was just that the chocolate had aged.
So here are the winners for the second round!
My Top Three:
Toblerone
Lindt
Ghirardelli
Raymond's Top Three:
Toblerone
Rittersport
Cadbury
We also decided to come up with different categories for grading the chocolate.
Here are the categories and the top chocolate(s) for each one.
For best "go-to" chocolate (As in, now that you've had a chocolate tasting, which will you likely buy when you're craving milk chocolate.) This does take into account price and availability to a small extent.
Ray's pick was Cadbury. Mine was Milka with Dove in a close second.
Most unique chocolate
Rittersport with corn flakes won hands down for both of us. There was just something really nice and balanced about milk chocolate with corn flakes.
The chocolate we actually bought the next time we wanted chocolate
Toblerone (Ray found a smaller portion of it and decided to get some.)
We had a marvelous time having a chocolate tasting and we enjoyed learning about and eating chocolate. We totally recommend trying a chocolate tasting yourself. Our suggestions would be to have the palate cleansers recommended by AllChocolate and definitely do not taste more than 4 or 5 in one session without a 15 minute break. Enjoy!